Police procedurals have always struck a chord with British audiences, but few have sparked as much conversation in recent years as ITV’s “Karen Pirie.” Born from the acclaimed novels by Scottish writer Val McDermid, the series breathes new life into the genre. With its gripping storylines, strong performances, and atmospheric Scottish settings, “Karen Pirie” has become a standout in the increasingly crowded world of TV crime dramas.
From Page to Screen: The Origin of Karen Pirie
The story of Karen Pirie began on the page in 2003 when Val McDermid introduced her as a determined young detective in “The Distant Echo.” McDermid, whose career spans three decades and includes multiple award-winning book series, designed Pirie as a cold case specialist working out of Fife, Scotland. Over the years, the series has delved into complex crimes, systemic injustices, and the lingering effects of trauma, all viewed through Karen’s sharp, empathetic lens.
With the books becoming bestsellers and earning critical praise, it was only a matter of time before Karen Pirie was adapted for television. ITV launched the series in 2022, initially drawing on “The Distant Echo” as its source material. The result was a critically lauded first series that averaged nearly 5 million viewers across the UK.
What Makes Karen Pirie Stand Out?
While there is no shortage of crime dramas on British television, “Karen Pirie” offers something distinct. The series centres on Detective Inspector Karen Pirie, played with nuance by Lauren Lyle, as she re-examines unsolved cases from decades past. The cold case format allows the show to explore Britain’s changing social landscape, the evolution of police work, and the enduring pain of unsolved crimes.
Lauren Lyle’s performance in the role has drawn special attention. Her portrayal captures both the determination and vulnerabilities of a detective working under public scrutiny and internal pressure. Many critics have noted that, unlike traditional, often male, “grizzled” detectives, Karen Pirie approaches her work with empathy, directness, and a touch of wry humour. This has resonated with a younger, more diverse audience and helped the series feel fresh and authentic.
Recent Success and the Return of Season Two
After a three-year wait, Karen Pirie returned for a second series in July 2025, drawing in viewers who were eager for new mysteries. This latest chapter adapts McDermid’s 2008 novel “A Darker Domain” and showcases picturesque Scottish locations, from sweeping coastal vistas to mysterious villages. The second season centres on the infamous 1984 abduction of Catriona Grant and her son Adam, a case that previously baffled police and press alike. When new evidence emerges, Karen must navigate both public pressure and her own doubts to get to the truth.
Across three lengthy episodes, the season keeps audiences hooked with tightly plotted twists and emotionally resonant character arcs. The show has been praised for its careful, steady pace and for allowing its complex story to unfold with subtlety.
Critical Reception and Ratings
“Karen Pirie” has not only won over viewers but also critics. The first series maintains a 91% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes, along with an average score of 8.6 out of 10. Reviewers at The Guardian highlighted its suspenseful plot, dry wit, and well-rounded characters, describing it as “clever and twisty” with “refreshingly cohesive storytelling.” Publications like The Independent have cited Lyle’s performance as a key reason for the show’s success, calling her portrayal “excellent” in a genre often dominated by toughened male leads.
These qualities echo through the second season, with commentators noting that the production has avoided the common pitfalls of formulaic storytelling. Instead, it offers something more akin to a puzzle box—delicate, layered, and rewarding for attentive viewers. The show’s thoughtful pacing and attention to character development have made it a favourite for Sunday night viewing and established it as appointment television.
A Closer Look at the Source: Val McDermid’s Influence
Much of the series’ success can be traced back to Val McDermid’s writing. McDermid, who grew up in Fife and often sets her novels in places she knows well, brings detailed realism to both her plots and her characters. Inspector Karen Pirie is a distinctly modern figure: she is quick to challenge outdated attitudes, open to new ways of solving cases, and deeply invested in justice for the victims she seeks to remember. The books have also allowed McDermid to explore social issues, from the legacy of the miners’ strike to the realities of modern policing.
There are now seven novels in the Karen Pirie series, with each book tackling a complex mystery linked to Scotland’s past and present. This depth of source material bodes well for the TV show’s longevity and suggests that more seasons may be in store.
Where Is Karen Pirie Filmed?
One of the show’s most striking features is its use of Scotland as both backdrop and character. From the historic streets of St Andrews to rugged coastal cliffs, the location work plays a crucial role in establishing atmosphere and providing visual distinction. Local tourism boards have credited the series for boosting interest in Scottish travel, and fans regularly praise the show’s authentic sense of place.
The Broader Impact: Contemporary TV and the Future of Crime Drama
The popularity of “Karen Pirie” aligns with a broader trend in British television: an appetite for intelligent, character-driven mysteries. The show stands alongside recent hits like “Line of Duty” and “Broadchurch” in proving that procedural dramas can be both commercial and critical darlings. Its success on both traditional broadcast and on-demand platforms like ITVX speaks to its wide appeal among different age groups.
Conclusion
“Karen Pirie” has quickly established itself as a defining crime drama for British television in the 2020s. With compelling female-led storytelling, authentic settings, and cleverly constructed mysteries, it appeals to both die-hard crime fans and viewers seeking something new. As interest in the novels continues to grow and with the success of its latest TV series, Karen Pirie looks set to be a fixture of the UK’s cultural landscape for years to come.
To read more click here
